The Technology Is Killing Me

I’ll begin by patting myself on the back, railing against the machine–and I’ll conclude with a number of confessions and some serious hand-wringing.  I might even gnash my teeth together regarding the various ways in which technology is killing me.

I congratulate myself for abstaining from cell phone use for a very long time.  I purchased my first cell phone ever in the summer of 2011–and I bought a shitty 3G iPhone for fifty bucks.  Most of the calls I get I miss because the phone is rarely on my person.  It’s no big deal.  People leave messages, just like they used to do on those crazy answering machines with the little micro cassettes, and when I get their messages, I call them back.  Because it’s a shitty 3G, it does only what I really need it to do: it functions as a telephone and as a message sending device.  There are no games or fancy apps.  Every once in a while I’ll check the weather or use the calculator, but rarely.  I feel pretty good, smug actually, about my propensity for resisting the smart phone siren call–and the siren call of half a dozen other technological advances that tend to use humans more than they are used by them.

This is what I’ve seen.  People walking together in public places, each with a phone in use, carrying on conversations with people who are not the people they are walking with in public places.  I have seen students in my classroom who cannot, literally, be without their phones in their hands, in their faces, in their ears, or on the desk in front of them.   They are attached to these devices as if they were appendages to their actual bodies.  If you removed the phone from the possession of many of these children you might expect to see them break out in cold sweats, convulse, maybe even vomit or bleed, or at least get out-of-control angry.  One student told a colleague of mine that if he took her phone her mother would kill him.  I’ve seen couples in clubs or in restaurants who sit together snuggly while they each surf the web on their phones.  I’ve seen students of mine on the road, driving and texting. Did you hear the story of the young couple in a fatal  auto accident who turned out to be texting each other in the car?  Moving from phones for a minute, I’ve seen kid after kid at my high school at the boy’s restroom urinals with their iPods blasting dub-step, metal, hip-hop, power pop, yes, blasting.  These kids can’t even take a piss without the stimulus of technology.  I hope to some day see a kid who’s pissing accidentally drop his phone or his pod into the toilet.  This would bring joy to my heart. I have countless times seen groups of kids in a standing huddle all simultaneously wearing ear-buds and trying to talk to each other over the noise drowning out the noise in their heads.

I worry that smart phones are making us dumb. We can’t find a place on a  map.  We can’t look up words in dictionaries.  We can’t wait.  We must have instant gratification.  We are constantly distracted.  We can’t be in a room by ourselves.  We can’t do ANYTHING without telling someone about it in a text or a post, and yet, we can’t look each other in the eye.  We can’t listen. We cannot endure silence.  We can’t do simple arithmetic. We don’t need to remember anything. Wikipedia will immediately answer all of our questions and we will immediately forget those answers. Twitter has reduced social discourse to a sound that birds make.  Henry David Thoreau was suspicious of the post office and the railroad.  Henry David Thoreau would hate us.

Okay, all you smart-phone-Mp3-player-kindle-reader-game-player-you-tube-facebook addicts: don’t you feel terrible?  Well, I have some issues of my own.  To wit:

Confession #1:  I got the dumb phone, but I bought my lovely wife a smart one.  She can’t stop playing with it.  I wish sometimes that her phone was as dumb as mine.

Confession #2:  I joined Facebook.

Confession #3: I bought an iPad.

Confession #4:  I got a Wii for the boy.

Confession #5: I fantasize about getting a new computer so I don’t have to carry the laptop up and down the stairs from the studio to the study.

So while I criticize from my lofty blog all these problems I see in our culture with the abuse of technology, I can’t leave Facebook alone for a day.  I go to the Huffington post several times in an hour.  It’s difficult to get my lovely wife and my sweet boy to stop playing with their devices.  Most of the daily cravings I have for new ways to improve my life come from images or toys or trinkets I’ve seen advertised in some way on the internet.  The web is an ever-present almost omniscient beast of distraction:  It keeps me from reading books, it keeps me from writing more often, it keeps me in a state of anxiety about what I must be missing–and while I could brag a blue streak about how great I am for not watching ANY commercial television for nearly a decade now, I know it’s true: the computer has replaced the television.  It’s no different.  It’s influences are deeper and more pernicious.  I would love to be able to unplug, but I can’t unplug.  I’ve got to see if I have new friends, find out what stupid things Republicans are doing, check out the bicycle I’ve been drooling over, look at tiny houses, see if anyone new has read or commented on my blog, stream some late-night TV, or, yes, I still do this, check to see if I have any email.  So old school.  The technology is killing me.

I’m not so far gone as some people I know or some people I see every day.  After all, my phone is dumb and I’d like to keep it that way.  But I worry  about my son.  I fret on a daily basis whether or not the iPad or the Wii were not the worst purchasing decisions I’ve ever made in terms of the health of my family.  But then I say to myself, dude, the technology will not go away.  The best you can do, perhaps, is not to abstain, but to learn and teach how best to live along side of it.  The greatest victory is perhaps that you’re still reading and writing, you’re still engaged in other endeavors, and when the weather is good, you’re still outside playing badminton or having light saber duels with your six year old.

Published by michaeljarmer

I'm a public high school English teacher, fiction writer, poet, and musician in Portland, Oregon

4 thoughts on “The Technology Is Killing Me

  1. In my view, technology is best adapted via integration. By that I mean expanding upon the cultural phenomena brought about either by existing tech or by other means. The automobile integrated well with the horse & buggy as it was a similar transport but used a different power source. Computers integrated well with the typical office as it integrated well into the typical workflow, taking over for the typewriter and the adding machine. Cell phones have integrated well with land-line phones, but through the integration of computers have become something quite different.

    What I think this means to raising your son is this: I’d integrate these technologies into your existing family culture. Using tech as a means to babysit would probably create more ear-budded high schoolers. Then again, you don’t know _why_ the kids are listening to what they’re listening to while they piss. Maybe they’re in a funk band and they’re listening to a tune they’re covering and the between-classes time is the only time they have to listen and study. Who knows? No one outside that kid knows what’s going on.

    It’s a tough row. Best sharpen your hoe.

  2. But then I say to myself, dude, the technology will not go away. The best you can do, perhaps, is not to abstain, but to learn and teach how best to live along side of it. The greatest victory is perhaps that you’re still reading and writing, you’re still engaged in other endeavors, and when the weather is good, you’re still outside playing badminton or having light saber duels with your six year old.

    I think this is the most important part of this post. I understand the hesitance to adopt another form of mind-sucking technology–as my mom would call it, “another screen”. When I was growing up, my family had a CRT TV that showed the news a few times a week and was occasionally, on rare circumstances, used to show movies we rented from the video rental store. We didn’t have cable, except for one brief stint which taught us quite quickly that it made no sense to pay for something that we weren’t going to watch. We didn’t have video game systems either, and I was almost certainly the last of my peers to get a cell phone, sometime in junior year of high school. I definitely understand the concern about too many attention-drawing devices.

    But the technology is there, and it’s widespread. I didn’t have a video game system in my house, but all my friends did, and I would go over and play with them when we weren’t riding bikes or playing with LEGOs or doing whatever other things we did as kids. There wasn’t any way my parents could realistically keep me unexposed to video games without exerting an arguably unreasonable amount of control over what I did when I played with my friends. Instead, they set an example at home and taught me how to be responsible. Rather than learning that video games or cable TV were bad and to be avoided, I learned how to use them responsibly.

    I think every generation has its new technology or new way of life that older generations look at skeptically. We’re a species whose innovation is ever-increasing, but as individuals we hate change, so every new development will be scrutinized by some as unnecessary. After all, we were doing just fine before [Twitter/cell phones/the Internet/the telephone/the automobile/the post office]. And while it’s important to be critical, I think it’s just as important to understand that new technologies bring new possibilities. I use Twitter–at least sometimes–as a creative tool, to try to express evocative imagery in a very small space. We’ve seen it used to connect protesters fighting dictatorships. Wikipedia may facilitate “drive-thru” knowledge usage for Americans bearing smartphones, but it also is being used to give children in developing countries nearly-free access to an unprecedented amount of human knowledge, faster and more accessibly than any hardbound encyclopedia could.

    In the end, the smart phone, the Wii, the iPad, Twitter, Facebook, Wikipedia–none of those are going to by themselves ruin our society. They don’t have that power. It ultimately comes down to the people using them, and that’s where we can step in and try to exemplify making use of technology–instead of being used by it.

    Always a pleasure to read your thoughts.

    1. Thanks, Spencer, for your story and your thoughtful response. Thanks, too, for this reminder about how many cool and revolutionary influences these technological developments have wrought. It’s easy to forget about those things in the immediacy of your own stuff.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: